05. Models for Railway Track Allocation

The optimal track allocation problem (OPTRA) is to find, in a given railway network, a conflict free set of train routes of maximum value. We study two types of integer programming formulations for this problem: a standard formulation that models block conflicts in terms of packing constraints, and a novel formulation of the `extended' type that is based on additional `configuration' variables. The packing constraints in the standard formulation stem from an interval graph and can therefore be separated in polynomial time. It follows that the LP-relaxation of a strong version of this model, including all clique inequalities from block conflicts, can be solved in polynomial time. We prove that the LP-relaxation of the extended formulation can also be solved in polynomial time, and that it produces the same LP-bound. Albeit the two formulations are in this sense equivalent, the extended formulation has advantages from a computational point of view. It features a constant number of rows and is amenable to standard column generation techniques. Results of an empirical model comparison on mesoscopic data for the Hanover-Fulda-Kassel region of the German long distance railway network are reported.