Blocked Bloom Filters with Choices

Abstract

Probabilistic filters are approximate set membership data structures that represent a set of keys in small space, and answer set membership queries without false negative answers, but with a certain allowed false positive probability. Such filters are widely used in database systems, networks, storage systems and in biological sequence analysis because of their fast query times and low space requirements. Starting with Bloom filters in the 1970s, many filter data structures have been developed, each with its own advantages and disadvantages, e.g., Blocked Bloom filters, Cuckoo filters, XOR filters, Ribbon filters, and more.
We introduce Blocked Bloom filters with choices that work similarly to Blocked Bloom filters, except that for each key there are two (or more) alternative choices of blocks where the key’s information may be stored. When inserting a key, we select the block using a cost function which takes into account the current load and the additional number of bits to be set in the candidate blocks. The result is a filter that partially inherits the advantages of a Blocked Bloom filter, such as the ability to insert keys rapidly online or the ability to slightly overload the filter with only a small penalty to the false positive rate. At the same time, it avoids the major disadvantage of a Blocked Bloom filter, namely the larger space consumption. Our new data structure uses less space at the same false positive rate, or has a lower false positive rate at the same space consumption as a Blocked Bloom filter. We discuss the methodology, cost functions for block selection, engineered implementation, a detailed performance evaluation and use cases in bioinformatics of Blocked Bloom filters with choices, showing that they can be of practical value.
The implementation of the evaluated filters and the workflows used are provided via Gitlab at https://gitlab.com/rahmannlab/blowchoc-filters.