Search Results

Record/Replay (RR) allows developers to record an execution and then replay it exactly as it was recorded. RR enables deterministic replay of non-deterministic behaviors in a different environment than the one used for the recording, which can capture complex bugs in production and find the root cause during development. Unfortunately, support for RR still introduces a non-negligible amount of performance overhead, which limits its applicability. Two main sources of such overhead in state-of-the-art RR systems are: multi-threading, and I/O bound workloads. To ensure high-fidelity when replaying multi-threading execution, recordings either capture the total order of events, which the replayer then enforces, or capture a partial order that requires further processing before replay. Recording also effectively doubles the I/O performed as the recorder needs to perform the original I/O and then record it to a log. Such increased I/O severely limits the performance of I/O dominated workloads. In this paper, we present two complimentary techniques to reduce the overhead of RR. First, we introduce Relaxed Total Order (RTO), an online-computable weakening of total order that preserves the cross-thread constraints needed for replay while avoiding unnecessary serialization. We design RTO to be compatible with Multi-Version eXecution (MVX), enabling online deterministic replay without pre-processing the recording log or heavyweight coordination. We formalize RTO’s strictness and correctness, showing that it is a novel point between partial- and total-order. Our prototype implementation on top of an existing state-of-the-art RR system reduces recording overhead from 21.0% to 15.3% and halves replay overhead from 67.5% to 31.7%. Second, we combine RR with Multi-Version eXecution (MVX) to eliminate RR’s poor performance on I/O-bound workloads. Our hybrid design uses a follower variant to absorb the extra I/O needed for logging, and to backfill as much I/O as possible from the same underlying system, keeping the user-facing leader off the critical path. Our prototype reduces the overhead required to record I/O bound programs from 192.5% to just 25.5%, without penalizing other more common workloads. Together, RTO and hybrid MVX/RR substantially narrow the gap between today’s RR systems and practical, low-overhead, always-on deployment.

Support for Record Replayer (RR) introduces a non-negligible amount of performance overhead, which limits its applicability. Two main sources of such overhead in state-of-the-art RR systems are: multi-threading, and I/O bound workloads. To address the former, we introduce Relaxed Total Order (RTO), an online-computable weakening of total order that preserves the cross-thread constraints needed for replay while avoiding unnecessary serialization. RTO is compatible with Multi-Version eXecution (MVX), enabling online deterministic replay without pre-processing the recording log or heavyweight coordination. To address the latter, we combine RR with Multi-Version eXecution (MVX) to eliminate RR’s poor performance on I/O-bound workloads. Our hybrid design uses a follower variant to absorb the overhead needed for logging and I/O, keeping the user-facing leader off the critical path. The artifact contains the source code of our prototype, software used to evaluate the techniques' performance, and scripts to automate and summarize the results.