Search Results

The Hella-Vilander game for modal logic is a model comparison game that captures the formula size necessary to separate sets of pointed Kripke structures. We introduce the ℳ-ON game as a modification of this game. Our game captures the necessary number of modal operators, i.e., ◇ and □ instead of formula size. We use our game to show that the bi-implication ↔, sometimes also called equivalence, enables us to write modal logic formula with significantly fewer modal operators. With this we show, that with bi-implications we can also write significantly shorter modal logic formulas. This result holds even if only special classes of Kripke structures are considered. To be more precise we show that there is an exponential succinctness gap between modal logic and its extension with bi-implication on the class of structures with a transitive and reflexive accessibility relation, as well as on the class of structures with a symmetrical and reflexive accessibility relation. Lastly we show that for the class of structures with a transitive and symmetrical accessibility relation this succinctness gap disappears.